Last week I presented all the contents of my book to a group of eager learners. It was a group of eight. Some were pastors. Most were college students. Everyone asked excellent questions, they provided quality feedback, and my first round of book editing received great boost.
Here are some reflections after my week with this group:
First, I'm wondering about the order of presenting the material. My book covers New Testament background, the Gospels, Paul's letters, and writings from the Ante-Nicene period. I decided to start with Jesus and his disciples and examine texts that appear to suggest Jesus and his followers received payment for preaching, or that they relied on the hospitality of others. We talked about traditional Jewish understandings from the first century, covering topics like hospitality, voluntary associations, and philosophical schools, and how each handled matters of money and pay. From there we looked a Paul's writings. This is where things got really challenging. Without the writings from the Apostolic Fathers, students had a hard time reading Paul, and what he may have been saying, in a new way. It wasn't until day 4 of our 5 day course that we looked at the post-apostolic texts and saw that my seemingly unusual approach to some texts was actually confirmed by later writings.
In retrospect, I'm wondering if it might have been better if I had introduced sources like the Didache and Justin Martyr a bit earlier. Of course, had I done that, there may have still be questions about their reliability but at least students would have had a heads up about how the church seemed to function just after what we read in the New Testament.
Second, I'm thinking about how to make it more engaging for students. Because so much of my material is new and not easily found by looking at what most commentators say about texts, I found myself tied closely to my notes and unable to think creatively about pedagogy. As I become more comfortable with my positions, I'll need to plan questions for groups and times for students to explore on their own. Even though I had written the book, there were parts of the material I struggled with. That made it hard to create a good back and forth with students. This was especially noticeable when students had new ideas or wanted to point out additional things in the Greek text that I had not noticed. There were times when I realized that a position I was arguing in my book was not very strong and other times when I realized a weak argument in the book was actually much better than I realized, simply by speaking it out loud. While the class was gracious with me, in future classes I will be certain to know my positions, clearly present those with solid supporting arguments, and offer students a variety of perspectives while inviting them to wrestle for themselves.Third, it was so valuable to teach the contents of my book before going through another round of editing. While it was uncomfortable when I realized that some positions I was presenting turned out to be untenable, I discovered some new ideas and perspectives, ones that had much stronger support, simply by doing additional prep for the class and by listening to the class ask questions and challenge assumptions. It was as though I had multiple editors sitting with me, helping me think through New Testament texts, contemporary applications of those texts, and things I may have missed about Jewish backgrounds. I was especially impressed on the last day when many new insights and perspectives emerged as we discussed the implications of Christians shifting attention from paid pastoral positions to ones where a group of volunteers might one day take on leadership roles in smaller groups. One of the most fascinating questions that surfaced was about what might happen if we stopped thinking about the institution of the church and its success. If we stopped thinking about church, and focused on God and God's mission, would that be so bad? So many interesting possibilities emerge if we don't have to think about the continuation of an institution.
Overall, I want to offer a huge shout out to my class: Juwon, Jenessa, Paris, Jacob, Josh, Caleb, Luke, and Elijah. I am grateful for your keen insights and gracious engagement with my ideas and arguments. I had an exhaustingly rich and rewarding week with you. Thank you! My book will be stronger because of you.







